From comp.chem.msu.su!f118.n5020!f400.n5020!f44.n5000!f4.n5000!not-for-mail Fri Sep 29 10:06:52 1995
Path: comp.chem.msu.su!f118.n5020!f400.n5020!f44.n5000!f4.n5000!not-for-mail
Newsgroups: fido7.su.hardw.support.arvid
Distribution: fido7
X-Comment-To: All
From: Nick Malyshevsky <Nick.Malyshevsky@p1.f4.n5000.z2.fidonet.org>
Date: Sun, 24 Sep 95 18:40:02 +0300
Subject: Video-8 and Hi8
Message-ID: <812032472@p1.f4.n5000.z2.ftn>
Organization: The Yellow House Chief Doctor
X-FTN-AREA: SU.HARDW.SUPPORT.ARVID
X-FTN-MSGID: 2:5000/4.1 3066a1d8
X-FTN-Tearline: GoldED 2.50.Beta6+
X-FTN-Origin: The Yellow House Chief Doctor (2:5000/4.1)
X-FTN-SEEN-BY: 50/316 319 332 502 520 461/121 464/200 465/11 469/999 4615/4 4625/1
X-FTN-SEEN-BY: 5000/4 10 26 27 31 44 45 46 51 61 68 71 73 100 5010/21 5012/4 5015/28
X-FTN-SEEN-BY: 5020/62 109 118 144 177 310 322 350 400 463 603 604 5026/9 5031/3
X-FTN-SEEN-BY: 5047/12 5049/1 5050/9 5051/15 5054/10 5057/1 5060/88 5080/22 75
X-FTN-SEEN-BY: 5085/250 5090/3
X-FTN-PATH: 5000/4 44 5020/400
X-FTN-PATH: 5020/118
Lines: 113

=============================================================================
* Forwarded by Nick Malyshevsky (2:5000/4.1)
* Area : SU.HARDW.TV.VIDEO (SU.HARDW.TV.VIDEO)
=============================================================================

   Hi, All!

   Хоть это касается и не совсем арвид-применяемых :) кассет, но сравнение фирм
кажется интересным.

   Кто не в ладах с немецким - перевожу заглавия колонок:

Column 1 - Preisempfehlung (recommened price in DM);   - цена в DM;

Column 2 - Bildtest (picture quality) (max.40 points); - качество изображения;

Column 3 - Tontest (max.10 points);                    - качество звука;

Column 4 - Laborwerte (max.40 points);                 - качество изготовления;

Column 5 - Dropouts (max.10 points);                   - уровень выпадений
                                                         сигнала;

Column 6 - sum 2+3+4+5 = rating                        - общая оценка.

  Для Арвида особенно важна колонка N5.

   Bst rgrds,
            /OldNick

=============================================================================
* From : Andrey Chicherov, 2:5020/375 (Thursday September 21 1995 14:45)
* To   : All
* Subj : Video-8 and Hi8
=============================================================================
* Crossposted in SU.HARDW.TV.VIDEO
* Crossposted in RU.VIDEO
* Forwarded from NETMAIL by Andrey Chicherov (2:5020/375)
* Originally by: vlassov@fhi-berlin.mpg.de (2:50/128@fidonet.org)
* Originally to: Andrey Chicherov

Hi Andrey,

I have red a discussion concerning Video-8 and Hi8 casets and thought that
the following information would be interesting for the comunity of
fido7.video. I can read this news-group, but unfortunately am not allowed
to post in there. So if you find it possible, post the message below to be
available to everyone.

This is rating-list of videocasets
from German magazine "Video" of September 1995.

Column 1 - Preisempfehlung (recommened price in DM);
Column 2 - Bildtest (picture quality) (max.40 points);
Column 3 - Tontest (max.10 points);
Column 4 - Laborwerte (max.40 points);
Column 5 - Dropouts (max.10 points);
Column 6 - sum 2+3+4+5 = rating
[do not ask me what do these terms above mean]


Hi8                   1       2   3    4    5    6

TDK E5-90HME         29      36   5   28   13   82
Sony E5-90 HME       33      35   5   27   13   80
BASF E5-90 ME        30      35   5   27   12   79
Fuji E5-90 MEP       27,5    36   5   24   14   79
Maxell E5-90 XD-P    35      34   5   28    7   74
Fuji P5-90 MP        18,5    34   5   20   14   73
Sony P5-90 HMP       29      33   5   18   14   70
Scotch P5-90 MP      17      34   3   17   14   68
BASF P5-90 MP        20      33   5   19    9   66
TDK P5-90 HMP        21      33   5   17   11   66
Maxell P5-90 XR-M    20      33   4   19    7   63
Sony E5-120 HME      38      33   5   22    2   62


Video-8               1       2   3    4    5    6

Fuji P5-90 SHG       12,5    30   5   22   14   71
Fuji P5-90 MP        9,5     30   4   22   14   70
Fuji P5-120 SHG      16,5    30   5   21   14   70
TDK P5-90 HS         12,5    30   3   21   13   67
Maxell P5-90 HGX-M   14      30   2   20   13   65
TDK P5-90 E-HG       14,5    30   3   18   13   64
BASF P5-90 HG        10      30   2   19   12   63
BASF P5-90 PHG       12      30   2   21   10   63
Maxell P5-110 HGX-M  19      29   2   17   13   61
Kodak P5-90 MP       13      29   2   16   13   60
Konica P5-90 SXF     15      29   2   14   14   59
Scotch P5-90 MP      10,5    29   1   14   13   57
Philips P5-90 MP     12      28   1   13   12   54
Sony P5-120 HG       16      28   4   21    0   53
Sony P5-120 MP       14      28   4   20    0   52
Maxell P5-90 VX-M    12      28   2   17    0   47
Akai P5-90 SG        13      27   2   15    0   44
Raks P5-90SHG        7,5     28   0   12    0   40

Have fun,
Yuri

PS I would like to know an opinion about this information.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hello All!

  Может кому еще интересно будет.

With best regards,
Andrey.

-+- GoldED 2.50.Beta6+
 + Origin: MeDiann Professional Board, 7-095-209-7705, CM (2:5020/375)
=============================================================================

